Leasing (personal contract hire) is usually cheaper each month than buying the same car on HP, but you hand the car back with nothing to show for it. Buying costs more each month but leaves you with a car to sell. On a £28,000 car, three years of leasing costs about £12,600, while HP costs about £20,300 net after selling.
The answer depends on your mileage and how long you keep cars. This guide compares leasing and buying on the same £28,000 car, explains the early termination rules and sets out who each option suits.
What Is Car Leasing (PCH)?
Personal contract hire, usually just called leasing, is a long term rental. You pay a fixed monthly amount to use a new car for two to four years, then hand it back. There is no option to buy it and no balloon payment. The initial rental is typically one to six months’ payments upfront, most commonly one to three months (Gumtree, November 2026; carplus, November 2026). Small hatchback leases typically run from £150 to £250 a month (carplus, November 2026).

Business contract hire, or BCH, is the business version. Businesses can typically reclaim 50% of the VAT on monthly payments, 100% if the car is used exclusively for business, and lease payments are deductible for corporation tax (Gumtree, November 2026). A leased electric company car can be tax efficient: the benefit in kind rate for electric cars is 3% in 2025/26, rising to 9% by 2029/30. A personal lease has no benefit in kind tax.
What Does Buying a Car Mean?
Buying means the car ends up yours. Pay cash and you own it from day one. With hire purchase, or HP, you pay monthly and own the car after the final payment. With personal contract purchase, or PCP, you pay monthly plus a large balloon payment, the Guaranteed Future Value, at the end if you want to keep the car. See our guide to how car finance works, and our guide to PCP vs HP car finance.
Buying builds equity in an asset you can sell or trade in later. Leasing never does, however little you pay each month.
Leasing vs Buying: How Do the Costs Compare?
The comparison below uses one car, a £28,000 car, with the assumptions stated. They are an illustration, not a market quote.
| Leasing (PCH, 3 years) | Buying (HP, 4 years) | |
|---|---|---|
| Monthly payment | £350 | About £621 |
| Total paid | About £12,600 | About £29,800 in payments, about £32,300 including deposit |
| What you own at the end | Nothing | A car worth about £12,000 (assumed) |
| Net cost | About £12,600 | About £20,300 after selling |
The HP figures assume a £2,500 deposit, £25,500 financed at 7.9% APR over 48 months, a monthly payment of about £621. Total payments come to about £29,800, and total outlay including the deposit to about £32,300. With an assumed residual value of £12,000 after four years, the net HP cost after selling is about £20,300. The lease is £350 a month for 36 months, £12,600 in total, and you hand the car back owning nothing.
Note the terms differ: three years for the lease against four years for HP, so do not compare them as the same period. HP costs about £7,700 more in cash over the term, £20,324 against £12,600, but leaves you with a £12,000 asset. Leasing costs less in cash but leaves nothing.
Over a decade the balance tips the other way. Leasing a new car every three years for about ten years costs around £42,000 in total, while buying one car and keeping it for about ten years costs around £33,000 to £35,000 including maintenance (carplus, November 2026). Part of the reason is depreciation: premium petrol and diesel cars lose 50 to 60% of their value over the first three years (carplus, November 2026). In short, leasing is cheaper month to month and in cash over one short term; buying is usually cheaper over a decade.
What Happens If You End a Lease Early?
This is the biggest legal difference between the two. There is NO voluntary termination right on PCH. Voluntary termination under section 99 of the Consumer Credit Act 1974 lets you return the car once you have paid half the total amount payable, but it applies to HP and PCP only. PCH is a hire agreement, not a regulated credit agreement, so that right does not apply (Ocean Finance, November 2026; carleasedealsuk.co.uk, November 2026).
Ending a lease early is usually possible, but it is expensive. A typical charge is around 50% of the remaining rentals, plus administration, damage and excess mileage charges (Gumtree, November 2026). There is no single formula: each lessor sets its own charge, so 50% is a common figure, not a standard rate (carleasedealsuk.co.uk, November 2026). Ask the funder to let you transfer the lease to another person, or negotiate with the funder directly. See our guide to car finance early settlement.
On PCP, the 50% point comes later than halfway through the agreement, because the large balloon payment counts towards the total amount payable (Ocean Finance, November 2026). If you are weighing up PCP, see our guide on whether PCP is worth it.
What About Mileage Limits and Damage Charges?
PCH and PCP both set mileage limits, with charges for exceeding them. The per mile rate is set in your contract, so check it before you sign. Buying has no mileage limits or excess mileage charges, which is why high mileage drivers are usually better off buying.
Damage is judged against the BVRLA fair wear and tear guidelines. Small scratches up to 25mm and light seat staining are usually acceptable; unrepaired impact damage, windscreen chips and tyre wear below the legal 1.6mm minimum are not (Gumtree, November 2026).
Two more costs to check. First, GAP insurance: if a leased car is written off, you can still owe the remaining rentals, so GAP cover is worth considering; see our guide on whether GAP insurance is worth it. Second, maintenance packs are usually an optional extra on a lease, not included by default, and they do not cover tyres and wear items unless the contract says so. Since April 2025, new electric vehicles are no longer exempt from Vehicle Excise Duty and now pay a first year rate (Gumtree, November 2026).
Which Is Better for You: Leasing or Buying?
| Your situation | Better option | Why |
|---|---|---|
| Low mileage, want a new car every 2 to 3 years, predictable costs | Leasing | Lower monthly payments, new car each time |
| High mileage, or you keep cars for many years | Buying | No mileage limits, cheaper over a decade |
| Want to modify the car or have no mileage worries | Buying | The car is yours to change and drive |
| Company car, especially an EV | Leasing (BCH) or salary sacrifice | Benefit in kind rate of 3% for EVs in 2025/26 |
| Tight budget but want to own something at the end | HP, not PCH | Monthly payments with a car to sell at the end |
There is no single right answer. Match the choice to your mileage and budget, and read the contract before you sign anything.
Frequently Asked Questions
Is leasing cheaper than buying a car?
Month to month, yes; over a decade, usually no. Leasing a new car every 3 years costs around £42,000 over 10 years, while buying and keeping one costs around £33,000 to £35,000 (carplus).
Can I end a car lease early?
Usually yes, but it is expensive: typically around 50% of the remaining rentals plus fees, and there is no voluntary termination right on PCH.
Can I buy the car at the end of a lease?
No. A personal contract hire lease has no option to buy; that is what PCP is for.
Is buying better for high mileage drivers?
Yes. Buying has no mileage limits or excess mileage charges, while leasing and PCP both do.
Do I need GAP insurance on a leased car?
It is worth considering, because if a leased car is written off you can still owe the remaining rentals.
Written by the Apriliapartsbuyer editorial team, covering UK car finance guides. This article is for general information only and is not financial advice.











