Cheapest Cars to Insure for New Drivers (UK 2026)

Small hatchback car ideal for new drivers with open trunk

The cheapest cars to insure for new drivers are small city cars in insurance groups 1 to 5, led by the Hyundai i10 in group 1. A 17 year old pays around £1,240 to £1,640 a year for comprehensive cover on a group 1 to 4 car. A black box policy can cut the premium by 20 to 40 percent.

Insurance is often the single biggest running cost for a new driver, so the car you choose matters as much as the policy you buy. Small cars with small engines, strong safety ratings and cheap parts sit in the lowest insurance groups, and that keeps the premium down. This guide ranks the cheapest cars to insure, explains what makes them cheap, and sets out guideline premiums for 17 year olds. For how the groups themselves work, see our guide to how insurance groups work.

Which Cars Are Cheapest to Insure for New Drivers?

The table below ranks the cheapest cars to insure for new drivers. Groups come from RAC, Simply Quote, Brumble, Howden and Parkers. Stars come from Parkers and Simply Quote. Premiums come from the Learn and Drive composite, based on Car Insurance Expert 2026 and rebased to the Confused.com Price Index age 17 average of £1,695 a year, for March to May 2026, for comprehensive cover and a standard 17 to 18 year old profile. Where a figure is not stated, this guide says so rather than guessing it.

Car Insurance group Euro NCAP Guideline premium, age 17 to 18, composite
Hyundai i10 1.0 Group 1 automatic, group 2 manual 4 stars, 2020 About £1,240 a year
Volkswagen Up 1.0 Group 1 to 2 Not stated About £1,350 a year
Kia Picanto 1.0 Group 4, composite 1 to 4 Not stated About £1,290 a year
Toyota Aygo X 1.0 Group 5, composite 1 to 3 4 stars About £1,320 a year
Volkswagen Polo 1.0 Group 3, range 2 to 4 5 stars Not stated
Skoda Fabia 1.0 MPI Group 4 5 stars Not stated
SEAT Ibiza 1.0 Group 2, base 5 stars, 2022 Not stated
Ford Fiesta 1.1 Group 2 to 9 Not stated About £1,640 a year
Dacia Sandero Group 2 to 11 Not stated Not stated

Only the i10 1.0 automatic is group 1; the manual is group 2, according to Simply Quote, Brumble and RAC, and Parkers lists the 1.0 Premium 5 door automatic from April 2023 onward in group 1. The Up is discontinued, so buy used, as RAC notes for the Up and the Citroen C1. A higher trim of the same model can sit in a much higher group: the Ibiza FR 1.0 TSI 115 is group 13, according to Parkers, while the base Ibiza is group 2. For cheap first cars in general, see our guide to the best cars under 10,000 pounds.

What Makes a Car Cheap to Insure for New Drivers?

Man fastening seat belt in a car for safety before driving

Small, low powered engine: smaller engines are statistically linked to fewer high speed collisions, keeping insurance groups low. That is why the cars in the table above all use 1.0 or 1.1 litre engines.

Strong safety rating: the i10 scored 4 stars in the 2020 Euro NCAP test, with adult protection at 69 percent and child protection at 75 percent, and the Ibiza scored 5 stars in 2022, with adult protection at 83 percent and child protection at 82 percent, according to Parkers. The old version of this post said the i10 had a five star rating. That was wrong and has been corrected to 4 stars. Simply Quote lists the i10 as 3 stars, which conflicts with Parkers and the official Euro NCAP 2020 result; this guide uses 4 stars. For safety in more detail, see our guide to the safest cars in the UK in 2026.

Good security features: alarms, immobilisers and tracking systems reduce theft risk, which insurers factor into pricing.

Affordable, widely available parts: common mainstream models have cheaper repair costs than rare or specialist models. Aim for insurance groups 1 to 5, according to Simply Quote and Brumble.

Insurance groups run from 1 to 50, and they are set by the Group Rating Panel, with insurer representatives convened by the ABI and the Lloyd’s Market Association and administered by Thatcham Research. Brand new model ranges launched from 1 August 2024 use a Vehicle Risk Rating from 1 to 99 instead. The cars listed here are older ranges, so their groups still apply.

How Much Does Insurance Cost for a New Driver?

Measure Figure Source
Average UK comprehensive premium £560 a year, Q1 2026 ABI
Average premium for 17 year olds £1,932 a year, Q3 2025 ABI
Confused.com age 17 average £1,695 a year, Mar to May 2026 Confused.com Price Index
New driver on a group 1 to 4 car £1,240 to £1,640 a year Learn and Drive composite
Range across all new drivers £1,800 to £3,000 a year Learn and Drive composite

Quotes vary widely by postcode, named drivers and telematics, so treat the figures as a comparison between cars, not as a quote. Bumper.co quotes lower figures, at £750 for the i10, £800 for the Picanto, £900 for the Up and £1,250 for the Polo, for a 17 year old living at home with parents, which is a different profile. The table above uses the composite and its stated profile.

What Else Cuts the Cost?

Black box policy: telematics tracks your driving and can cut premiums by 20 percent to 40 percent for safe driving, according to Simply Quote. Pairing a low group car with a black box policy is the strongest saving in this guide.

Add an experienced named driver: adding a parent as a named driver can lower the perceived risk on the policy.

Pay annually: pay annually rather than monthly where possible, since monthly payments often include additional interest charges.

Buy used: a used car is often cheaper to insure than a new one because its value is lower, but the insurance group matters more than the age of the car.

Cars to avoid: hot hatches such as the Ford Fiesta ST and VW Golf GTI, sports cars such as the Mazda MX-5 and BMW Z4, large SUVs such as the Range Rover and BMW X5, and performance saloons such as the BMW M3 and Audi RS4, according to Brumble. Those cars sit in high groups and carry high premiums for a new driver.

Should You Buy New or Used?

A new group 1 car such as the i10 comes with a manufacturer warranty, with Hyundai offering a 5 year unlimited mileage warranty, but it costs more to buy and insure. A used car in the same group is usually cheaper to insure because its value is lower. Check the group for the exact trim before you buy: the i10 automatic is group 1 but the manual is group 2, and the Ibiza FR is group 13 while the base Ibiza is group 2. Always get quotes for two or three cars before you buy, and check the MOT history on GOV.UK for a used car. If you are borrowing to buy, see our guide on how car finance works, and for GAP cover on a first car, see is GAP insurance worth it.

Frequently Asked Questions

What is the cheapest car to insure for a 17 year old?

The Hyundai i10 1.0 automatic in group 1, at around £1,240 a year on the composite, according to Learn and Drive.

Does a used car cost less to insure than a new one?

Often yes, because its value is lower, but the insurance group matters more than the age of the car.

What is a black box policy?

Telematics that tracks your driving and can cut premiums by 20 percent to 40 percent for safe driving, according to Simply Quote.

Does a low insurance group guarantee cheap insurance?

No. Your age, postcode, named drivers, mileage and telematics also matter.

Are electric cars cheap to insure for new drivers?

Not necessarily. Battery replacement and specialist repair costs can push EVs into higher groups than expected.